Manor Lords Review: A Deep Dive into Medieval Grand Strategy Manor Lords is poised to be a landmark title in the city-builder strategy genre, offering a fresh perspective on medieval settlement management.

Manor Lords is poised to be a landmark title in the city-builder strategy genre, offering a fresh perspective on medieval settlement management. This Manor Lords review delves deep into its gameplay, mechanics, graphics, and performance, providing discerning PC gaming enthusiasts with an informed perspective on its early access build. But is Manor Lords worth buying? Let's find out.

Gameplay & Mechanics: The Intricacies of Economic Simulation

The economic simulation in Manor Lords is where the game truly shines, offering a level of depth that rivals even established titles like Crusader Kings III. Unlike the more character-driven focus of Crusader Kings, Manor Lords places emphasis on the interconnectedness of your settlements and their economies. Resource management is paramount, requiring a keen understanding of supply chains and the impact of your decisions on overall prosperity.

Depth of Resource Management and Trade

The game's resource management system goes beyond simple collecting and stockpiling. You'll need to consider the fertility of your land when planning crop rotations, the availability of resources like iron ore and clay, and the needs of your population. Decisions regarding crop rotation (three-field vs. two-field), livestock management (sheep for wool vs. oxen for plowing), and crafting specialization (blacksmithing for tools vs. brewery for ale) directly impact your town’s economy.

For instance, opting for a three-field rotation improves long-term soil fertility, leading to higher yields but requires more labor. Choosing sheep for wool production provides a steady income stream but necessitates careful pasture management to prevent overgrazing. Specializing in blacksmithing provides superior tools, boosting overall efficiency, while a brewery increases happiness and provides a valuable trade commodity, potentially making your settlement wealthy. Trade routes must be carefully managed to ensure your settlements have access to essential goods, and regional wealth must be carefully protected.

Economic Challenges and Micromanagement

While the economic system offers meaningful challenges, it can occasionally devolve into repetitive micromanagement, particularly when attempting to optimize multiple resource chains simultaneously. The early game provides a relatively smooth learning curve, but as your settlement grows, maintaining equilibrium across different production chains becomes a significant undertaking. If Manor Lords can successfully streamline some of these processes, it will hit all the marks as a grand strategy game.

Narrative: Emergent Storytelling and Unpredictable Events

The emergent storytelling in Manor Lords is reminiscent of RimWorld, with player actions and random events shaping the history of settlements and characters. The game doesn’t present a predefined narrative; instead, it fosters a dynamic environment where unexpected events can significantly alter your trajectory.

Impact of In-Game Events

Specific in-game events, such as a devastating plague wiping out 30% of the population, a successful trading partnership with a neighboring lord granting access to iron ore, or a peasant revolt triggered by excessive taxation, can drastically impact your overall narrative and strategic choices. For example, a plague forces you to prioritize healthcare and sanitation, potentially diverting resources from economic development. A successful trading partnership could enable rapid expansion but also create dependence on a foreign power. A peasant revolt necessitates a reevaluation of your taxation policies and military preparedness.

These events create a sense of unpredictability and force players to adapt to ever-changing circumstances. Manor Lords has the potential to deliver unique and compelling narratives with each playthrough. If the game had multiplayer features, it would be even more unique.

Graphics: Environmental Detail and Seasonal Changes

The environmental detail in Manor Lords is striking, particularly its depiction of seasonal changes and their impact on the landscape. The game’s visual fidelity is comparable to Kingdom Come: Deliverance, capturing the beauty and harshness of medieval life.

Environmental Realism and Gameplay Impact

The changing seasons affect gameplay in numerous ways. Crop yields decrease by 50% during winter, necessitating careful planning and resource stockpiling. Travel times double due to heavy snow, impacting trade and military movements. The availability of resources like berries and herbs is limited to specific seasons, forcing players to diversify their economies.

The realistic depiction of the environment adds immersion and strategic depth to the game, demanding players consider the long-term consequences of their actions.

PC Performance: CPU Optimization Challenges

CPU optimization remains a challenge in Manor Lords, particularly with large populations and complex settlements. The impact on CPU usage, core utilization, and frame rates with varying population sizes is noticeable, especially with larger settlements.

CPU Usage and Frame Rate Data

Testing with an Intel i9-13900K (at 5.5 GHz) and an AMD Ryzen 7 7700X (at 5.0 GHz) revealed the following trends:

• 50 Inhabitants: Smooth performance on both CPUs, with average frame rates exceeding 100 FPS.
• 200 Inhabitants: Slight performance degradation, with average frame rates dropping to around 80-90 FPS.
• 500 Inhabitants: Noticeable performance drop, with average frame rates fluctuating between 50-70 FPS, and occasional stuttering.
• 1000 Inhabitants: Significant performance issues, with average frame rates dipping below 40 FPS, and frequent stuttering, particularly on the Ryzen 7 7700X.

This is reminiscent of Cities: Skylines II, where pathfinding calculations and agent simulation can overwhelm the CPU. Frame time graphs illustrate performance degradation as population increases, with 99th percentile frame times highlighting stuttering, which is something that needs to be addressed. Addressing pathfinding is something the Manor Lords developers are prioritizing.

Overall Experience: Strategic Depth and Accessibility

The overall strategic depth of Manor Lords balances accessibility with intricate economic and military simulations. Its city planning, resource management, and military campaigns provide layers of strategic options for both casual and hardcore players.

Strategic Complexity and Tactical Battles

Compared to the Total War series, Manor Lords offers a more granular level of control over your settlements and resources but may not match the tactical depth of Total War: Medieval II in terms of battle tactics. Total War provides complex military unit control; Manor Lords is far more simplistic.

The game allows players to build aesthetically pleasing towns and delve into intricate economic and military management. It caters to both casual players who enjoy building visually appealing settlements and hardcore players who demand strategic depth.

Military Campaign

Manor Lords is shaping up to be an exceptionally deep and rewarding medieval strategy game. Its realistic approach to city-building and economic management sets it apart. However, the current early access build does have some performance issues, especially with larger populations. If you are looking for a strategy game, this one is worth buying in early access.

Conclusion

Manor Lords offers a compelling blend of city-building and grand strategy, with a focus on realism and emergent storytelling. While the early access build has some performance hurdles to overcome, its depth of gameplay and engaging mechanics make it a promising title for discerning PC gaming enthusiasts. Keep an eye on Manor Lords.

Are you looking for more grand strategy game reviews? Check out XenGamer.com for all your gaming needs.