Keychron Q1 Pro Review: A Gamer's Deep Dive into Custom Mechanical Keyboards The Keychron Q1 Pro is making waves in the custom mechanical keyboard community, and for good reason.
The Keychron Q1 Pro is making waves in the custom mechanical keyboard community, and for good reason. This 75% layout board promises premium build quality, extensive customization, and a comfortable typing experience, all while maintaining a reasonable price point. But does it live up to the hype? At XenGamer.com, we pride ourselves on delivering sharp, practical insights for PC gaming enthusiasts. In this comprehensive review, we’ll delve into every aspect of the Keychron Q1 Pro, from its CNC aluminum case to its QMK/VIA programmability, to help you decide if it's the right keyboard for your gaming setup. Whether you are a seasoned keyboard enthusiast or simply looking for an upgrade from your run-of-the-mill membrane board, we will uncover the pros and cons of this device.
Build Quality and Design: A Premium Feel
The first thing you'll notice about the Keychron Q1 Pro is its solid construction. The case is CNC-machined from 6063 aluminum, giving it a hefty and premium feel. It's available in several aesthetically pleasing colors, including Carbon Black, Navy Blue, and Silver Grey. The anodized finish is smooth and resistant to scratches, ensuring the keyboard maintains its visual appeal even after prolonged use. This robust construction immediately sets it apart from cheaper, plastic-cased alternatives. If you are wondering what is CNC Aluminum?, it is when computers controls machine tools in the manufacturing of parts.
Inside the case, sound-absorbing PORON foam is strategically placed to dampen vibrations and reduce noise, contributing to a cleaner and more satisfying sound profile. The internal layout minimizes hollowness, further enhancing the acoustics. The 75% layout, with its dedicated function row, strikes a good balance between functionality and desk space efficiency. Cable management is also well-considered, with a recessed USB-C port that allows for clean routing. The Keychron Q1 Pro layout allows for all the necessary keys to be present while saving as much space as possible.
The gasket mount design with a leaf-spring plate is a key element of the Q1 Pro's design. This mounting style suspends the switch plate between the top and bottom case halves using gaskets, providing a degree of flex and cushioning that improves typing comfort and contributes to a more muted sound. More specifically, what is gasket mount keyboard? This design uses a dampening material, like PORON foam, to reduce vibrations for better sound and feel. The result is a deep, resonant "thock" that many mechanical keyboard enthusiasts find highly desirable.
Comfort and Typing Feel: Long-Session Bliss
Comfort is paramount for long gaming and typing sessions, and the Keychron Q1 Pro largely delivers. The included double-shot PBT keycaps with a Cherry profile feel great under the fingers. PBT plastic is known for its durability and resistance to shine, ensuring the keycaps retain their texture and appearance over time. The Cherry profile is a popular choice, known for its comfortable sculpted shape.
The typing feel, of course, depends on the switches you choose. The Keychron Q1 Pro switch options include Keychron K Pro Brown tactile switches and Keychron K Pro Red linear switches.
- Keychron K Pro Brown: These tactile switches provide a noticeable bump when actuated, giving you clear feedback for each keystroke. This is ideal for typing and gaming scenarios where accuracy is crucial.
- Keychron K Pro Red: These linear switches offer a smooth, consistent keypress with no tactile bump. They're often preferred for fast-paced gaming where speed and quick reactions are essential.
The gasket mount feel with the leaf-spring plate significantly impacts the typing experience. The added flex provides a noticeable cushioning effect, reducing fatigue during extended use. It's not overly bouncy, but rather a subtle and refined level of give that enhances overall comfort. When comparing other keyboards, note that Gasket mount keyboard designs are known for their comfort and dampening which can add to a more enjoyable typing experience.
Performance Testing (Gaming Responsiveness): Fast and Reliable
Gaming performance is a key consideration for any keyboard, and the Keychron Q1 Pro doesn't disappoint. Let's examine its responsiveness and stability.
Keyboard Latency
We measured the Keychron Q1 Pro latency test using KeyboardTestUtility, running five trials and averaging the results. The Q1 Pro averaged 4ms of latency. For comparison, the Razer Huntsman V2 Analog averaged 2ms.
While the Razer Huntsman V2 Analog boasts a lower latency, the 2ms difference is unlikely to be noticeable for most gamers.
Subjective Gaming Feedback
We recruited three experienced gamers (Diamond rank or higher in Valorant and Apex Legends) to provide subjective feedback on the perceived responsiveness of the linear vs. tactile switches. Here's a summary of their ratings (1-5, with 5 being the most responsive):
| Switch Type | Valorant | Apex Legends | Average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keychron Red | 4.3 | 4.7 | 4.5 |
| Keychron Brown | 3.7 | 4.0 | 3.85 |
The linear Red switches were consistently rated as more responsive, particularly in fast-paced scenarios requiring rapid key presses. The tactile Brown switches were still deemed viable but less ideal for competitive play where split-second reactions matter. Many users wonder "Is Keychron Q1 Pro good for gaming?". These results suggests that it can be a suitable choice for casual gamers.
Polling Rate Stability
Using a USB analyzer, we confirmed that the Q1 Pro consistently achieves a 1000Hz polling rate, ensuring stable and responsive performance. This is crucial for minimizing input lag and maintaining accuracy in fast-paced games.
Customization Options (QMK/VIA): Unleash the Power
One of the biggest selling points of the Keychron Q1 Pro QMK/VIA is its support for QMK/VIA firmware. This open-source software allows for unparalleled customization, putting you in complete control of your keyboard's functionality.
With QMK/VIA, you can easily:
- Remap Keys: Change the function of any key to suit your preferences or specific game requirements.
- Create Custom Macros: Program complex sequences of commands to be executed with a single keypress. For example, you could create a macro for performing a specific combo in a fighting game or a buy script for Counter-Strike 2.
- Program Multiple Layers: Create different profiles for different games or applications, allowing you to switch between customized layouts on the fly.
The QMK VIA setup guide provides easy to follow steps to customize the keyboard and create custom key binds.
The interface is relatively intuitive, though some familiarity with keyboard programming concepts is helpful. The benefits of open-source firmware extend beyond basic customization. You can create complex lighting effects, implement custom tap dance functions (performing different actions based on how many times a key is pressed), and even fine-tune the keyboard's behavior at a low level.
Here are a few practical examples of what you can achieve:
- Dedicated Discord Mute Button: Remap a key (e.g., the Scroll Lock key) to instantly mute/unmute yourself in Discord.
- One-Press Screenshot Capture: Assign a key to trigger a screenshot using your operating system's built-in functionality.
Using QMK/VIA means answering the common question "Does Keychron Q1 Pro support macros?" with a resounding yes.
Switch Performance: Brown vs. Red
The Keychron Q Pro Brown switches review suggests that they may be suitable for gaming, but the reds come out on top due to speed. Let's take a look at the K Pro Red and Brown switches:
| Feature | Keychron K Pro Brown | Keychron K Pro Red |
|---|---|---|
| Actuation Force | 45g | 45g |
| Travel Distance | 2.0mm | 2.0mm |
| Tactile Feedback | Distinct Bump | Linear |
The Brown switches provide a noticeable tactile bump, making them ideal for users who prefer feedback with each keystroke. The Red switches, on the other hand, offer a smooth and consistent linear feel, which is often preferred for fast-paced gaming. Some users have noted minor spring ping or scratchiness on some switches, but this is generally minimal and can be addressed with lubrication.
For gaming, linear switches like the Reds are often favored for their speed and responsiveness, particularly in FPS games. Tactile switches like the Browns are better suited for typing and games where accuracy is more important than speed. You can always determine what are the best switches for the Keychron Q1 Pro by testing them out!
Comparison with Glorious GMMK Pro and Drop ALT
When considering other keyboards, asking the question "How does the Keychron Q1 Pro compare to the GMMK Pro?" will help narrow down which to buy. The Keychron Q1 Pro Alternatives also include the Drop ALT. Here's a comparison of the Keychron Q1 Pro with the Glorious GMMK Pro and the Drop ALT:
| Feature | Keychron Q1 Pro | Glorious GMMK Pro | Drop ALT |
|---|---|---|---|
| Build Quality | CNC Aluminum | CNC Aluminum | CNC Aluminum |
| Mounting Style | Gasket Mount | Tray Mount | Integrated Plate |
| Typing Feel | Cushioned, Thocky | Stiffer, More Direct | Firmer, More Solid |
| Sound Profile | Deep, Resonant | More Clacky | More Metallic |
| QMK/VIA Support | Native | Requires Flashing | Native (with Issues) |
| Value for Money | Excellent | Good | Fair |
| Layout | 75% | 75% | 65% |
The GMMK Pro offers a more affordable entry point into custom mechanical keyboards, but requires flashing aftermarket firmware for full QMK/VIA support. The Drop ALT boasts a compact 65% layout but has known compatibility issues with QMK. The Keychron Q1 Pro strikes a good balance between features, ease of use, and overall value.
Here's a quick guide on when to choose each:
- Glorious GMMK Pro: For those seeking the most affordable entry point into the custom keyboard hobby.
- Drop ALT: For users who prioritize a compact 65% layout and are willing to troubleshoot potential QMK compatibility issues.
- Keychron Q1 Pro: For its balanced features, excellent build quality, and ease of use.
Value for Money: Is It Worth It?
With a price of around $200, the Keychron Q1 Pro is a significant investment. The question "Is the Keychron Q1 Pro worth it?" depends on individual needs and priorities. The CNC aluminum case, QMK/VIA support, and comfortable typing experience justify the premium price. Cheaper alternatives often compromise on build quality (using ABS keycaps and plastic cases) and customization options. However, alternatives cheaper than the Keychron are available from other brands.
Strengths and Weaknesses
Let's recap the key strengths and weaknesses of the Keychron Q1 Pro:
Strengths:
- Excellent Build Quality: The CNC-machined aluminum case feels incredibly solid and durable.
- Customizable QMK/VIA Firmware: Unleash the full potential of your keyboard with extensive remapping and macro capabilities.
- Comfortable Typing Experience: The gasket mount and PBT keycaps contribute to a pleasant and fatigue-free typing experience.
- Versatile Switch Options: Hot-swappable sockets allow you to easily experiment with different switch types to find your perfect feel.
Weaknesses:
- Potentially High Price: The $200 price tag may be a barrier for some users.
- Limited stock switch options There are no heavier tactile options like Browns that come with the keyboard.
- Requires assembly: The Q1 Pro is a barebones kit, which may be daunting for some users.
Conclusion: A Top Contender in the Custom Keyboard Arena
The Keychron Q1 Pro is an excellent choice for serious PC gamers and custom keyboard enthusiasts. Its premium build quality, extensive customization options, and comfortable typing experience make it a top contender in its price range. While the price may be a hurdle for some, the Q1 Pro offers a level of quality and customization that is hard to find in cheaper alternatives. If you're looking to elevate your gaming and typing experience, the Keychron Q1 Pro is definitely worth considering. You can find the Keychron Q1 Pro on Keychron's Website.
